Client Reviews
From local home sellers & buyers

If you're buying or selling in the Williams Bay / Lake Geneva area, do yourself a favor and work with Joel Reyenga!Joel's knowledge of the area and the local market is unparalleled — he brought insider insight into our specific property that made a real difference throughout the transaction. Our sellers had unrealistic pricing expectations from the start — even when we came in near asking, they didn't take the offer seriously and seemed to be holding out for something that was never going to materialize. It was a genuinely strange dynamic to navigate. Joel read the situation clearly, helped us understand what was actually driving it, and guided us strategically on pricing, timing, and communication so we didn't get stuck waiting on a seller who wasn't being realistic. He also helped us navigate some tricky inspection issues, knowing exactly when to hold firm and when to concede so things could keep moving. He clearly knows the other players in the industry too, and that made a real difference in getting a difficult transaction across the line.He recommended an excellent inspector we trusted immediately, along with a great attorney — his network of local pros is a real asset.What stood out just as much was how he showed up as a person. He texted back within the hour and called often to walk us through each step. It never felt like he was there to close a deal — instead, he was working through the process as our advocate, willing to do whatever was best for us. He was patient and present, and he takes things in stride in a way that made the whole process so much less stressful.Joel doesn't just feel like a realtor, he feels like a friend. We're looking to buy another house in the area just to work with him again (not kidding!).Can't recommend him highly enough!

I had a fantastic experience working with Joel on my recent home purchase in Abbey Springs. From start to finish, he was incredibly responsive and communicative, always making himself available to answer questions and guide me through the process.What really stood out was his dedication—he even worked while on vacation to help me finalize my offer, staying up until midnight to make sure everything came together smoothly. That level of commitment made a huge difference.As a first-time property owner in Wisconsin, I especially appreciated Joel’s thoughtful advice and local expertise. He made what could have been a complicated process feel seamless and straightforward. I couldn’t be happier and would highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy in the area.

Joel and Kim are an amazing team. We had a unique property to sell for a loved one who had passed. The Reyengas expertly guided us through this difficult process. Joel and Kim are responsive professionals who know the market and gave us honest, confident advice. Moreover they are compassionate, dedicated to customer service, and tireless when it comes to the ultimate goal: selling a home.

Joel and Kim made the whole home-buying process so easy and enjoyable. We looked at a bunch of houses across the state before finding “the one,” and they were patient, responsive, and genuinely cared about helping us find the right fit. Joel sent us weekly updates, offered great advice, and handled the negotiations perfectly. Couldn’t recommend them more!

Kim & Joel Reyenga take the time to truly understand not just what you’re looking for, but what matters to you and why. They bring a rare combination of deep local knowledge, strong community relationships, real estate expertise, and a thoughtful, solutions-oriented approach that makes a real difference. They have been an invaluable partner throughout the process and are a team who not only help make deals happen, but help turn ideas into reality. Joel & Kim lead with insight, trust, and genuine investment in their clients, and I would confidently recommend them to anyone looking for a personal home, rental property, or development opportunity!